• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • About
  • Lifestyle Galleries
  • Custom Furniture
  • Color Options
    • Brown Maple
    • Cherry
    • Elm
    • Hard Maple
    • Hickory
    • QSWO
    • Red Oak
    • Walnut
    • Wormy Maple
    • Specialty Finishes
    • Paints
    • Office Chair Leather
    • Genuine Leather
    • Faux Leather
    • Ultraleather
    • Fabric Options
      • Office Chair Fabric
      • Standard Fabric
      • Premium Fabric
      • Easy Living Performance Fabric
      • Revolution Performance Fabric
      • Microfiber Suede
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
Amish Custom Furniture logo with a white horse-and-buggy silhouette inside a burgundy oval, representing handcrafted Amish furniture in Williamsburg VA

Amish Custom Furniture

Handcrafted Fine Furniture

  • Bedroom
        • Bedroom CollectionsBedsCollectionsChestsDressersNight StandsWardrobes & ArmoiresMirrorsJewelry StorageOccasionalsHolin Bed
  • Youth
        • Children's CollectionsCribsChildren's BedsChests & DressersNightstandsPlay RoomChairs & Tables
  • Dining Room
        • Dining CollectionsTablesChairsBar Chairs/StoolsIslandsHutchesBenchesStorage CabinetsServing CabinetsKitchen AccessoriesCollections
  • Living Room
        • Living Room CollectionsOccasional TablesTV StandsSofasAccent ChairsLove SeatsEntrywayFireplace MantelsDecorCollections
  • Office
        • Office CollectionsDesksFile CabinetsOffice ChairsBookcasesGun CabinetsCollections
  • Outdoor
        • Garden BenchesOutdoor TablesGlidersOutdoor ServingOutdoor Occasional TablesPorch ChairsSwingsAccessories
  • About
  • Custom Furniture
  • Color Options
    • Brown Maple
    • Cherry
    • Elm
    • Hard Maple
    • Hickory
    • QSWO
    • Red Oak
    • Walnut
    • Wormy Maple
    • Specialty Finishes
    • Office Chair Leather
    • Faux Leather
    • Genuine Leather
    • Ultraleather
    • Paints
    • Outdoor Fabric
    • Sunbrella Fabric
    • Office Chair Fabric
    • Standard Fabric
    • Premium Fabric
    • Easy Living Performance Fabric
    • Revolution Performance Fabric
    • Microfiber Suede
  • Reviews
  • Contact
  • Lifestyle Galleries

Pie Safes

All Storage CabinetsCategory ImageCuriosCategory ImageJelly CupboardsCategory ImagePantriesCategory ImagePie Safes
Product Type
All Storage CabinetsCategory ImageCuriosCategory ImageJelly CupboardsCategory ImagePantriesCategory ImagePie Safes
Filters

Mission Style

Shaker Style

Traditional Style

Best Sellers

Quick Ship

Mission Style

Shaker Style

Traditional Style

Best Sellers

Quick Ship

Showing 1–16 of 41 results

  • Auburn Pie Safe

  • Butler Pie Safe

  • Lynwood Pie Safe

  • Ozark Pie Safe

  • Spencer Pie Safe

  • Arts & Crafts Cabinet

  • Bunker Hill Pie Safe

  • Classic Copper Panel Pie Safe

  • Classic Copper Panel Pie Safe With Drawers

  • Classic Copper Panel Pie Safe With Drawers – 3 Panel Door

  • Classic Copper Pie Safe – 3 Panel Door

  • Classic Raised Panel Pie Safe

  • Classic Raised Panel Pie Safe With Drawers

  • Classic Raised Panel Pie Safe With Drawers – 3 Panel Door

  • Classic Raised Pie Safe – 3 Panel Door

  • Colebrook Cabinet

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • Next Page »

Footer

Products

  • Bedroom
  • Youth
  • Dining Room
  • Living Room
  • Office
  • Outdoor

Navigation

  • Home
  • About
  • Customer Reviews
  • Custom Furniture
  • Color Options
  • Contact Us

Hours

Thursday: 10:00AM – 6:00PM
Friday : 10:00AM – 6:00PM
Saturday: 10:00AM – 5:00PM

Closed Sunday-Wednesday

Contact Us

Amish Custom Furniture
Victory Village Shopping Center
6610 Mooretown Road, Suite V
Williamsburg, VA 23188
(800) 786-0407

© 2025 Amish Custom Furniture | Privacy Policy | Designed & Hosted By VIZTECH Furniture